The safest route to a first product role is from the inside — moving roles at the company you already work for. Moti Peretz, VP Product at Orca Security, points out that the company has a strong interest in your success too, but warns it takes patience. Arbel Zinger of Melio reaches the same conclusion from another angle: product manager is usually a second job, not a first, so the best way in is through an adjacent role such as engineer, analyst or customer support, staying close to the product from there.
When there is no internal path, you need an X-factor — the thing that makes a recruiter read your resume to the end. According to Moti, that can be product work in your current role (a PRD, customer calls, working with a designer), a side project you brought users to, or a seemingly irrelevant background that fits the product's domain exactly. He says Orca's product team is roughly half cyber people and half people from outside.
Ela Hatzav is a case in point: from psychology and tourism, through a decade at Taglit, to Product Manager at Wix. She argues that excelling at anything, not necessarily academics, is a strong predictor of success in product, and that her own barrier was psychological rather than technical — the fear of not excelling.