Hadas Sheinfeld | Takhles Episode: How Do You Break PM Loneliness with a Peer Circle? - Product Builder Podcast episode with Eyal David
Updated:

Hadas Sheinfeld | Takhles Episode: How Do You Break PM Loneliness with a Peer Circle?

Host: · Guest: Hadas Sheinfeld · About the host

According to Hadas Sheinfeld, founder of The Guild for Product Managers, loneliness is the most common pain of product managers, at a small startup and at Google alike. Her fix is a standing peer group outside your organization, made of people who understand your world. A mentor gives one perspective, their own; a peer group gives several and support on every decision.

In this episode

  • Loneliness is the common pain of product managers, regardless of company size: Hadas was alone at a small startup, on Clicktale's management team, at Google and at Datagen.
  • The mental load of product management surprises everyone who moves into it: what to deliver tomorrow, next week, in three months and in a year are all running at once.
  • It's often easier to consult with people outside your organization, who understand the world but don't sit in the same company.
  • A mentor is good, but gives a single angle, theirs. A peer group gives several perspectives.
  • A peer group doesn't need to be big: three product managers who met by chance by the coffee at a conference have met once a month like clockwork for ten years, backing each other on every decision.

Episode Description

In this Takhles episode, a segment from the full conversation with Eyal David, Hadas Sheinfeld explains why product managers are so lonely: at Clicktale she was alone for years, and as VP Product she sat on the management team as the only woman besides the VP HR; at Google and at Datagen she was still alone, because everyone is busy with their own thing and the role's mental load is huge. She explains why a mentor alone isn't enough, and tells the story of the peer group she started with two product managers she met during a break at the Product X conference, which has met once a month for ten years, and of the forums she set up later: a forum of women on startup management teams and a Lean In circle of Women PMs at Google Europe.

Chapters

  1. 0:00 · The loneliness of product managers: from Clicktale to Google
  2. 1:56 · Supportive communities outside the organization
  3. 3:07 · A mentor vs. a peer group
Read the full transcript
Full transcript with speakers and timestamps

Selected quotes

“That's my thing. My thing is the loneliness of the product manager, woman or man.”
— Hadas Sheinfeld
“I'm in favor of getting advice from anyone you can, but you need to remember that the mentor gives their own perspective.”
— Hadas Sheinfeld
“Many times it's more comfortable with people who aren't in your organization. Really, they're outside, but they understand the world.”
— Hadas Sheinfeld

Questions & answers

Why do product managers feel lonely?

According to Hadas Sheinfeld, because there's usually no one else in the organization in the same role, everyone is busy delivering their own thing, and the mental load is high: you're constantly juggling tomorrow, next week, three months and a year. It happens at a small startup and at Google alike.

A mentor or a peer group?

Hadas is in favor of getting advice from anyone you can, and at Clicktale she had an amazing mentor who helped her a lot. But a mentor gives only their own perspective, and after a while you understand how they think. A peer group gives a range of perspectives.

How did Hadas Sheinfeld's first peer group start?

During a break at the Product X conference she met two product managers by chance, and they said they had to make themselves a group. They picked up the gauntlet, and for ten years now they've met once a month like clockwork and consulted on every decision.

Should you look for peers inside your organization or outside it?

Hadas says it's often more comfortable to really open things up with people who aren't in your organization but understand your world.

People & resources mentioned

Companies & orgs

  • The Guild for Product Managers
  • Clicktale
  • Google
  • Datagen
  • Product X — product management conference

Tools

  • Lean In Circles
Takhles Episode Product Management Loneliness Peer Group Mentoring Career