Hadas Sheinfeld | The Loneliness of Product Managers and How to Break It - Product Builder Podcast episode with Eyal David
Updated:

Hadas Sheinfeld | The Loneliness of Product Managers and How to Break It

Host: · Guest: Hadas Sheinfeld · About the host

Hadas Sheinfeld is a product consultant and founder of the Guild for Product Managers, with about 20 years in product management at Clicktale, Google and Datagen. In her view, product managers' biggest problem is loneliness, and the fix is building a standing peer group outside your organization where you can talk openly about failures and get real advice. Her key lesson from a failure at Google: strategy is always a game of compromises, but without a clear vision of where you're taking the product, the compromises swallow everything.

In this episode

  • Strategy is always a game of compromises, but you need a clear vision of where you're taking the product. At Google, Hadas was so busy with details and mockups that when the VP asked "where would you take this?", she had no answer.
  • Product managers are lonely, at startups and at Google alike. The fix is building a standing peer group, preferably outside your organization, of people who understand your world. Hadas's group with two other product managers has met monthly for ten years.
  • A mentor gives one perspective, their own. A peer group gives several perspectives and a safe place to talk about failures, and that's also the test of a good group: whether it feels comfortable to share things that didn't work.
  • Product managers suffer more from absent managers, who are hard to get feedback and backing from, than from micromanagement.
  • Inappropriate behavior in the room has to be stopped in that moment and in that forum, without drama. If it's only addressed afterwards on the side, everyone in the room learns that it's okay to talk that way.
  • Middle managers have the hardest job. The advice: invest in your people. Never cancel a one on one, start it with "how are you," and invest in their learning, or the team turns into a feature factory.

Episode Description

Hadas Sheinfeld, a consultant and founder of the Guild for Product Managers, was employee number 11 and later VP Product at Clicktale, a product manager at Google Israel and at Datagen, and runs content for the Product X conference. In conversation with Eyal David she explains how the Guild works, small groups of product managers from different companies learning from each other in confidence, and why participants' biggest surprise is how much everyone is in the same boat. She shares real failures: a tough meeting at Google where she presented a roadmap she didn't stand behind, and a senior executive pouncing on her at Clicktale, and what she learned from each. Along the way she gives practical tools: how to spot vanity metrics, why inappropriate behavior must be stopped in the moment, how to start a peer group, why you have to get your hands dirty with AI tools, and why middle managers should invest in their people first.

Chapters

  1. 1:18 · Who is Hadas Sheinfeld: Clicktale, Google, Datagen and the Guild
  2. 3:32 · What the Guild for Product Managers is and what a session looks like
  3. 5:26 · We're all in the same boat: micromanagement vs. absent managers
  4. 6:42 · Metrics, RICE and dashboards that don't tell the story
  5. 8:24 · Calling bullshit on vanity metrics, and a 10x target
  6. 11:10 · Setting up for success: the conversation with the CPO
  7. 12:50 · The loneliness of product managers
  8. 15:57 · Mentors, peer groups and support groups
  9. 20:26 · Why we need to talk about failures
  10. 21:25 · The Google screw-up: a roadmap without a vision
  11. 28:33 · Clicktale: boundaries on the management team, startup vs. corporate
  12. 30:50 · Stopping inappropriate behavior in real time
  13. 37:13 · How to start a peer group: three tips
  14. 39:59 · The AI corner: get your hands dirty
  15. 43:34 · Advice for middle managers: invest in your people
Read the full transcript
Full transcript with speakers and timestamps

Selected quotes

“When you build a strategy, it's always a game of compromises, but you need to have a vision of where you want to take it.”
— Hadas Sheinfeld
“It has to be stopped that same second. The second it happens, in the forum where it happens.”
— Hadas Sheinfeld
“I heard that Jensen Huang doesn't do one on ones. Fine, you're not Jensen Huang.”
— Hadas Sheinfeld

Questions & answers

Who is Hadas Sheinfeld?

An independent product consultant and founder of the Guild for Product Managers, with about 20 years in the field. She was employee number 11 at Clicktale and later its VP Product, a product manager at Google Israel on a large infrastructure product, a product manager at Datagen (machine learning and computer vision), and runs content for the Product X conference.

What is the Guild for Product Managers?

A learning format Hadas developed: groups of ten to twelve product managers at a similar experience level from different companies, meeting online for 90 minutes plus two half-day workshops. Each session combines experience, frameworks and best practices with open sharing of what works and what doesn't, under a confidentiality commitment.

How do you start a peer group for product managers?

First, just start: post a call-out, set a date and don't give up even if few people show up. Second, lead by example, for instance by opening with your own screw-up, and set goals. Finally, watch out for the participant who takes all the oxygen in the room and handle it in a one-on-one conversation.

What does Hadas Sheinfeld recommend doing with AI tools?

Get your hands dirty: block regular time in your calendar and actually work with the tools, because they change every day. She runs every query in parallel in ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude to compare them, and with Guild alumni she compared Bolt, Lovable and Base44.

What is Hadas's advice for middle managers in product?

Invest in people: never cancel a one on one, start it by asking how they are, and invest in the team's learning through regular learning sessions or courses. Without that the team gets sucked into delivery alone and becomes a feature factory.

People & resources mentioned

People

Companies & orgs

Tools

Product manager loneliness Peer groups Failures Product strategy Metrics Stakeholder management Middle managers AI