"Success won't happen on my watch": How a 100-year-old company innovates | Shay Cohen (Tnuva) - Product Builder Podcast episode with Eyal David
Updated:

"Success won't happen on my watch": How a 100-year-old company innovates | Shay Cohen (Tnuva)

Host: · Guest: Shay Cohen · About the host

A large corporation innovates successfully when it acts as a real beta site for startups and manages expectations for long cycles, not when it just writes a check. According to Shay Cohen, Chief Innovation Officer of the Tnuva Group and head of its corporate venture capital fund, most corporate innovation efforts fail for lack of patience: it took Tnuva 25 years to build its dairy-alternatives growth engine, so whoever leads innovation has to say openly that success may not come on their watch.

In this episode

  • Most corporate innovation fails because people expect quick success. It took Tnuva 25 years to build its dairy-alternatives growth engine, so an innovation leader has to tell their managers honestly that success may not happen on their watch.
  • A strategic investor runs the same checklist as a financial investor, but adds questions only someone living the industry can ask: how long to commercialize, to reach the shelf and to clear regulation.
  • Israel is an excellent beta site for food companies: a small Western market of ten million people, curious consumers who adopt innovation, and penetration costs far lower than New York.
  • When foodtech venture capital collapsed, a corporation's role became being a seal of quality: investing, acting as a beta site and reducing risk, so the startup can more easily raise from financial investors.
  • Bringing a startup into a corporation isn't just writing a check, it means rallying the organization from within. When managers say something won't work, reflect that back to the startup to sharpen it.
  • Half of the Tnuva fund's investments go to smart industry: AI and robotics on the factory floor, rapid quality testing, energy management and supply chain, partly because fewer people want to work in manufacturing and logistics.

Episode Description

Shay Cohen has led innovation at the Tnuva Group for eight and a half years. Tnuva is Israel's leading food company, celebrating 100 years and producing 4.5 to 5 million products a day. In this episode he explains the difference between a financial and a strategic investor, why Israel is the world's best beta site for foodtech companies, and how the fund splits its investments half into foodtech and half into smart industry, AI and robotics. He describes a joint development of an electric refrigeration system for delivery trucks, the collapse of foodtech venture capital and the new role of corporations as a seal of quality for startups, and why most innovation processes in organizations fail: no patience for 15- and 25-year cycles.

Chapters

  1. 0:00 · Opening: Shay returns from Kiryat Shmona
  2. 1:25 · Who Shay Cohen is and what Tnuva is today
  3. 4:30 · The scale: 4.5 million products a day
  4. 5:00 · The fund: orders of magnitude and what it invests in
  5. 6:00 · Financial investor vs. strategic investor
  6. 8:30 · Why Israel is the perfect beta site
  7. 13:00 · The collapse of foodtech venture capital
  8. 16:00 · 50/50: foodtech vs. smart industry
  9. 22:30 · Energy, supply chain and infrastructure
  10. 26:50 · A real example: electric refrigeration for trucks
  11. 30:00 · Protein, sports nutrition and the GO brand
  12. 32:00 · Functional nutrition: why consumers want products that do them good
  13. 33:00 · How the big players really manage to innovate
  14. 35:00 · The art of rallying an organization around a startup
  15. 37:30 · The bubble: why investors poured so much money into foodtech
  16. 41:30 · Vegan, meat substitutes and why tofu consumption is rising
  17. 42:00 · Fiber: is it the next protein?
  18. 43:50 · Why most innovation processes in organizations fail
  19. 46:15 · 25 years of dairy alternatives, and success that isn't on your watch
Read the full transcript
Full transcript with speakers and timestamps

Selected quotes

“People like me, in roles like mine, need to say honestly to their managers: success may not be on my watch.”
— Shay Cohen
“It's not just writing the check. If I really want to be a startup's strategic partner, I have to rally the organization.”
— Shay Cohen
“Regulation for us is a big issue, it can be the difference between a five-year cycle and a 15-year cycle.”
— Shay Cohen

Questions & answers

Who is Shay Cohen?

Shay Cohen is Chief Innovation Officer of the Tnuva Group and manages the group's corporate venture capital fund, a role he has held for eight and a half years. He oversees the portfolio, the open innovation platforms and growth deals, and Tnuva is a partner in the foodtech incubator in Kiryat Shmona.

What is the difference between a financial investor and a strategic investor?

Both look at the size of the opportunity, team quality and fundability. A strategic investor like Tnuva puts much more weight on the company's cycle, time to commercialization and market, regulation, and on its own ability to be a force multiplier: a production beta site, supply chain and brands.

What does Tnuva's venture capital fund invest in?

Roughly half goes to foodtech for next generation products, for example alternative protein (the Alternative brand) and sports nutrition, and half to smart industry: AI, robotics, rapid quality testing, energy management and supply chain. The fund focuses on the stage between Pre-Seed and Series A.

Why is Israel a good beta site for foodtech companies?

It is a small Western market of about ten million people, with curious consumers who adopt innovation. Penetration costs are much lower than in the United States, and partnering with a leading manufacturer gives a startup access to production lines, regulatory know-how and the shelf without limiting it in the rest of the world.

Why do most innovation processes in organizations fail?

According to Shay Cohen, the main reason is impatience. In the food industry a cycle can take 15 years and building a category 25 years, so you need to manage expectations up front and accept that success may not arrive on the watch of whoever started the process.

People & resources mentioned

People

Companies & orgs

Tools

  • Claude
Corporate innovation Corporate venture capital Foodtech Tnuva Food security Beta site Smart industry Alternative protein